Reviews are pouring in for Jay-Z's "American Gangster" and they are very, very positive. Diddy and The Hitmen (LV, Sean C. and Mario Winans) created the album's sound, producing 6 tracks. Here's a sampling of reviews.
Boston Globe:
One of the main pluses of "American Gangster" is it gets Diddy off the party circuit and back into the studio doing what actually made him famous. As a producer, Diddy's feel for '70s soul is impeccable, and the choogling congas, deep bass, and smoky blaxploitation atmospheres are a boon to tracks like "American Dreamin' " where a lone male falsetto hollers about the inner-city blues, Marvin Gaye-style.
The Daily Orange:
Purist fans of Jay-Z are going to celebrate his latest effort for its sharp lyricism and gritty portrayal of the drug underworld, a pronounced move away from last year's "Kingdom Come." Those looking for Jay-Z lyrics idolizing commercialism will not find them here.
Newsday:
"American Gangster" is bold, both in concept and in execution, with Jay-Z telling the story of a Brooklyn teen getting into the drug trade and then getting stuck in it. Jay does it in character, as if it were a series of monologues crafted into a one-man play. However, it is no one-man effort, as the musical backdrops - many crafted by Diddy and the Bad Boy Entertainment's production team The Hitmen, as well as Pharrell Williams, Jermaine Dupri, Kanye West and Just Blaze - are often just as remarkable.
Grade: A
USA TODAY:
While not officially linked to Ridley Scott's film, Jay-Z's bracing American Gangster concept album (* * * ½ out of four) draws its narrative from key scenes and revisits the rapper's hardscrabble origins and the dope-slinging lifestyle that he has been documenting since 1996's Reasonable Doubt.
AllHipHop.com:
With the unbearable, Lil’ Wayne assisted “Hello Brooklyn 2.0,” which ruins the album’s pacing, as the only flagrant misstep, American Gangster remains triumphant. There is no definitive radio smash hit present but that’s what keeps the project fresh. Jay goes from running the block to cornering the market without forcing the issue, leaving no need to question his G file.
9 stars out of 10.
EW.com:
Scott's Gangster follows the ascension of Frank Lucas, a notorious '70s heroin kingpin played by Denzel Washington. While Jay-Z does not make the ambitious leap of trying to write from Lucas' point of view, he does use the film's story and period vibe to color his own elaborate legend. On ''American Dreamin','' a Marvin Gaye sample provides the backdrop as Jay-Z wistfully recounts his early days as a wannabe dealer, scheming with his buddies. ''We need it now,'' he raps over the (slightly too) drippingly soulful Diddy-produced track, ''We need a town/We need a place to pitch/We need a mound.'' Nobody flips a drug-trafficking metaphor better. The more celebratory but less garish ''Party Life'' is another old-school contribution from Diddy, with Jay channeling slick '70s icons like Goldie and Superfly over a slow groove and silky guitar licks. ''So tall and lanky,'' he boasts in no hurry, ''my suit, it should thank me.''
B+
DJBooth.net:
American Gangster starts with Pray, a cinematic flashback that recounts Jay’s lost childhood innocence. The beat pulses with a deadly seriousness as Jay rhymes “everything I’ve seen made me everything I am/bad drug dealer or I victim I beg/what came first moving chickens or the egg?” If this album was a movie, Pray would be the creation of Hova, the birth of the best rapper/businessman hybrid hip-hop’s ever seen. Moving on with the cinematic metaphor, the next scene would be Sweet, a track that has Jay swimming in the rewards of his success. As good as Jay’s flow is throughout the album, and it’s extraordinary, Sweet shows the production is equally clutch. Diddy’s production team The Hitmen (LV, Sean C and Mario Winans) take soul and funk samples from the likes of Marvin Gaye and Curtis Mayfield to create a cohesive musical thesis so 70’s even I’m inspired to grow an afro. Listening to Sweet is like watching the original Shaft, only instead of Isaac Hayes we get intimidatingly powerful rhymes from Jay-Z.
4.5 Spins (out of 5)
HipHopDX.com:
... Ever the master of malicious coke raps with murmurs of lamentation and humanity, Jay makes it all go down sweeter with flows befitting of his reputation. Even though he rarely makes reference to himself as a rapper – largely sticking to character – his enduring brilliance is on display as much as it ever was without needing his insistence of it. Where this ranks amongst Jay’s catalogue will be determined as time passes. It certainly isn’t perfect, but it has a quality that should resonate into something special. ...
4.5 (out of 5)
HHNLive.com:
The "Intro" sets the tone for the album. The theme? "Gangster." This leads into "Pray", one of six songs produced by Diddy and the Hitmen (Sean C. & LV). A pulsating beat accented by faint background screams provide Jay the canvas to tell stories of watching drug sales and transactions go down. The song is a great departure from the glossy Jay-Z sound and takes it back to Jigga getting money by any means necessary. "American Dreamin'" is a smoothed out track from Diddy and co. with a bad 70s cop show sound (but in a good way). The song sees Jay telling the story of rising to the top and achieving success through moving the weight.
4 Kicks (out of 5)
Rolling Stone:
The music has the Seventies vibe of The Blueprint, led by Puffy, who oversees five tracks with his reassembled Hitmen production squad. Puff keeps the Harvey's Bristol Cream flowing through "Roc Boys," "Party Life" (with a killer Miami disco sample from Little Beaver) and "American Dreamin' " (with a Marvin Gaye chorus and fierce live drums from Mario Winans). ... the concept is really just a spark to get Jay started. Forget Frank Lucas: The real black superhero here is Jay, and with American Gangster, Gray-Hova is back in black.
4 (out of 5).
You may have noticed in the
Cheri Dennis iTunes Single of the Week flier, the URL badboyworldwide.com is featured near the bottom. The new home of
Bad Boy Online? No - just a typo. The Bad Boy site will remain at badboyonline.com.
Anthony Falzone at Slate writes an article about the legal defenses of sampling and questions why Diddy has not done more to defend it under the fair use doctrine.
Combs is not alone in his failure to bring fair use to the court's attention. Although the Beastie Boys successfully defended their right to sample a three-note flute sequence in one of their songs a few years back, they too failed to pursue the fair-use defense in that case.
Why would Combs, one of the biggest names in hip-hop, fail to defend sampling? Maybe it was simply inadvertence. Maybe it was a strategic decision (albeit a very bad one, as it turned out). Or maybe it was more calculating. Combs and his label can afford to pay for samples. Many aspiring artists and their fledgling labels—the next generation of would-be moguls hungry to unseat Diddy—cannot. Maybe Diddy cares more about the benefit of reduced competition than defending the work of the artist and the technique that helped create his empire. Tell us, Diddy, what were you thinking?
It's an interesting read, but I have one key problem with the assertion: Diddy is almost certainly going on the advice of his attorneys. He's not the attorney and he's not making assertions regarding copyright laws or fair use - that is how for attorneys. So, if you want to fault someone for this, I think the fault has to lie there as they decided what their legal strategy was and it didn't include fair use.
Diddy and Cassie attended Roberto Cavalli's Halloween at Cipriani's in New York.
whudat has a picture (note that there is some generally risque content at the link). Diddy went as
V from "V from Vendetta" while Cassie went as some sort of police officer, from the looks of it.
BallerStatus.com has an interview with Conrad Dimanche. It's a solid interview and well worth a read as the interviewer
BallerStatus.com: It seems like a lot of Bad Boy artists like Black Rob, Shyne, and G-Dep have had hard times making follow up albums -- due to obstacles like catching a case. Is it frustrating to build up an artist only to see their fire fizzle out from inescapable consequences?
Conrad Dimanche: It is frustrating because honestly, it's a lot of work to build em up to that point. It is what it is, that's life. It's not every artist -- there are the guys that manage to keep their heads straight.
BallerStatus.com: Bad Boy is often referred to as "the Shelf" because it seems as if there has been a pattern of signing artists and not doing much with them like eight year veteran Cheri Dennis. Why is that?
Conrad Dimanche: We don't have that many artists signed at this moment. 20 artists isn't a lot for any record label. Some people get signed and things don't work out, but I think we're doing pretty good as far as our ratio of artist we put out against other labels and the success we have with our projects. As far as albums that come out, we always go gold or platinum. And Sean, Mr. Combs, is always under the microscope, so we have to put out quality product.
From
AllHipHop.com's Rumors section:
So, Jigga Man has officially pushed “Blue Magic” into BonusCut Land and made “Roc Boys” the second single with the video that he just shot. According to Syn City, the vid features Diddy, Cassie, Nas, Mariah, Memph Bleek, Uncle Murda, Freeway, Beanie, Just and a bunch of other people ... The video was shot in the 40/40 Club and that’s all folks.
Via
Theo in the forums.
I've confirmed that "We Invented the Remix II" and "Press Play Remixes" remain two independent projects and not combined as I thought they may have been. But, it's really a question of when (and even if - I repeat, if) they will be released at all. "We Invented the Remix II" has been officially pushed off the December 18 date and is without a new release date.
"Just Watch Me" is in a similar place - it has been pushed off of it's January 15 release date and has not been assigned a new date.
It's over a week hold, but I just noticed the
HHNLive.com interview with Sean C. and LV. It's a good read.
JR: What was Jay’s reason for putting you on 6 tracks?
SC: You know we was forming the Hitmen situation. He was like this is the album that we can kind of bring it back. You know put that stamp back on it. So Puff hit us up and was like I’m going to work with Jay and I want him to do some joints with ya'll. This was like a month ago.
LV: This album moved real fast.
SC: Yea. Puff was like I want to do some joints with ya'll. Send me joints and I’m going to send them to Jay. And then that’s how it happens. We were in the studio chillin. Puff called Jay. Told him he has to come over here now. Jay got there in like 15 minutes flat. You know so that’s how it went down. You know Puff comes in and he adds his thoughts and stuff. You know his little thing of making records bigger. You may think he doesn’t do anything but he does do something. He definitely comes in. We might have something and he’ll say a certain thing. Like we need to put this there, or maybe call a certain musician to come in and direct him and it might make the record a lot bigger then we thought it would be. He produces it. You know a producer is just not someone who hits the drum machine or whatever. He comes in and orchestrates. He’s a conductor. We give him his props on that because a lot of people don’t.
LV: Because they just don’t want to, you know when n***** deserve props.